25 hyhmrright

iterate-skill Skill

端到端运行 Logic-Lens 技能改进循环——基线 → 诊断失败 → 编辑 → 同步缓存 → 重新评估 → 验证净收益 → 迭代直到干净。目标是提升技能评估分数或修复失败的评估模式时使用:"改进 logic-review"、"格式合规不通过,修一下"、"迭代这个技能直到评估通过"、"提高分数"、"针对最新失败再跑一轮"、"再跑一次迭代"、"根据评估调整技能描述/消歧表"。也可用于恢复之前的循环("接着上次继续改进","再来一……

安装方式:把技能目录放入 ~/.claude/skills/(Claude Code)或在 claude.ai 设置中启用;也可复制右侧安装命令一键添加。

查看源码

技能指令原文(SKILL.md)

iterate-skill — the Logic-Lens improvement loop

This is the harness orchestrator. It coordinates three agents and two support skills into one
deterministic loop that raises a skill's eval score without overfitting or grader-gaming.

Execution mode: sub-agent pipeline (generate → test → verify). Each step's output is the next
step's input, handed off through the filesystem (skills-workspace/iteration-/) and agent
return values. There is no peer-to-peer team chatter, so agents are spawned via the Agent tool —
always with model: "opus", and subagent_type set to the agent's own definition name (e.g.
subagent_type: "skill-editor"), not "general-purpose" — passing general-purpose would discard
the role/principles in .claude/agents/.md, defeating the harness. Agents return results to
this orchestrator, which owns state and the ship/rollback decisions.

Agents (who) — all in .claude/agents/, spawn by these exact subagent_type names:
| subagent_type | Role |
|-----------------|------|
| eval-failure-analyzer | Read-only: cluster failures, map to eval IDs, propose minimal edits |
| skill-editor | Apply one minimal, generalized edit; refuse grader edits |
| iteration-guard | Verify net gain vs variance; recommend SHIP / ROLLBACK / RERUN (orchestrator executes any revert) |

Support skills (how): sync-skill-cache (mandatory pre-eval gate), run-iteration-eval (run + grade).

Phase 0 — context check (initial / resume / partial)

Determine the run mode before doing anything:

  • ls -dt skills-workspace/iteration-*/ — if recent iterations exist and the user asks to "continue"

or "another pass" → resume: use the latest as baseline, skip re-baselining.

  • User provides a fresh target skill / new failure → initial: establish a baseline first (Phase 1).
  • User asks to redo just one mode or one skill → partial: scope the eval to the affected case IDs.

Confirm the target skill (which of the six logic-*) and the failing mode with the user if ambiguous —
do not guess which skill to mutate.

Phase 1 — baseline

If no usable baseline exists for the target: run the run-iteration-eval skill (sync cache, then a
full or mode-scoped run) to get summary.json. This is the number every later iteration is judged
against. Record its TAG.

Phase 2 — diagnose

Spawn eval-failure-analyzer (Agent, model: "opus") pointed at the baseline iteration dir. It
returns the prioritized failure modes, the exact failing eval IDs, and concrete edit proposals. Pick
the single highest (failure-count × ease-of-fix) mode for this iteration. One mode per iteration —
batching edits makes the verify step unable to attribute a regression.

Phase 3 — edit

Spawn skill-editor (Agent, model: "opus") with the chosen proposal. It applies one minimal,
generalized edit and reports what it touched + its risk note. If it refuses (the proposal needs a
grader/assertion change), drop that proposal and pick another mode — never relax the grader.

Phase 4 — sync cache (gate)

Run sync-skill-cache. If it reports DRIFT or a missing cache, stop the loop and surface it — an
unsynced eval grades stale content and wastes the run. Do not proceed to Phase 5 until it prints OK.

Phase 5 — re-eval

Run run-iteration-eval scoped to the affected mode's case IDs (cheap) for a fast read; widen to a
full run before a final SHIP decision. New summary.json, new TAG.

Phase 6 — verify

Spawn iteration-guard (Agent, model: "opus") with the baseline and candidate iteration dirs +
the editor's risk note. Act on its verdict:

  • SHIP → keep the edit; the candidate becomes the new baseline.
  • ROLLBACK → revert the edit (it named which one); baseline unchanged.
  • RERUN → the move is inside variance; rerun the affected cases 2–3× (Phase 5) and re-verify

before deciding.

Phase 7 — iterate or report

If SHIP and more modes remain and the score isn't at target → loop back to Phase 2 on the next mode.
Otherwise produce the 迭代报告 (in 简体中文): baseline→final overall + logic/format subscores, the
per-iteration Fix Log (mode, edit, verdict), and any mode left unresolved with why.

After reporting, offer Phase 7 evolution (harness skill): if the same failure mode recurs across loops,
or the editor keeps refusing the same proposal, propose a harness change (a new disambiguation rule in
the editor's principles, a new agent) and log it in CLAUDE.md's 변경 이력.

Data-passing protocol

  • File-based (durable handoff): all run artifacts live in skills-workspace/iteration-/;

agents read these dirs directly. Never delete a prior iteration dir — it is the rollback reference
and the audit trail.

  • Return-value based (control flow): each agent returns its report to this orchestrator, which

decides the next step. Agents do not call each other.

Error handling

1-retry then proceed-with-note. Specifically:

  • Cache sync fails → hard stop (never eval stale content). Report and fix the cache, don't skip.
  • An eval case errors (claude call fails) → the runner isolates it; re-run just that case once,

then proceed and note the missing case in the report rather than blocking the whole loop.

  • Guard says RERUN repeatedly (persistent variance) → report the move as "within noise floor,

inconclusive" rather than forcing a SHIP/ROLLBACK; widen the case set instead of trusting one run.

  • Conflicting signals (logic up, format down) → do not average them away; report both subscores

with their sources and let the user weigh, per the project's "logic = primary / format = gate" split.

테스트 시나리오

정상 흐름: User: "logic-review 的 format compliance 一直挂,迭代修一下。" → Phase 0 initial → Phase 1
baseline (format subscore low) → analyzer flags the format-label mode + eval IDs → editor sharpens the
literal label in the SKILL.md skeleton → sync OK → re-eval affected cases → guard: format up, logic
flat, no collateral → SHIP → report with before/after subscores.

에러 흐름: Editor's proposed fix requires loosening a grader assertion → editor refuses in Phase 3 →
orchestrator drops that proposal, picks the next mode from the analyzer's list, and continues — the
grader is never touched. If instead the cache sync prints DRIFT in Phase 4, the loop halts and reports
the drift before spending any eval tokens.